Star Island vs Fisher Island: Two Miami Enclaves Built on Scarcity

Star Island and Fisher Island sit only minutes apart by water, yet they represent two very different expressions of Miami privacy. One is a road-connected, single-family trophy island with famously scarce inventory; the other operates as a ferry-access, private-club ecosystem with its own ZIP code and national pricing superlatives. For buyers weighing legacy, logistics, and lifestyle, the distinctions matter as much as the views.