Six Fisher Island vs. Palazzo della Luna: Deposits, Timing, and the Price of Scarcity in 33109
Quick Summary
- 33109 scarcity shapes every negotiation
- Six Fisher: 40% pre-close deposits
- Palazzo: resale closings on delivered units
- Escrow rules influence buyer protections
Fisher Island’s pricing context: scarcity with a number
Fisher Island does not rely on hype. Its value proposition is structural: limited inventory, controlled access, and a pace that feels intentionally separated from the rest of Miami. Scarcity is not just a vibe here, it is measurable. Recent national coverage named ZIP code 33109 the most expensive in the United States, citing a reported median home price of about $9.5 million.
For buyers evaluating Fisher Island today, that headline functions less as trivia and more as context. It explains why securing a position can matter as much as negotiating price, and why contract terms, escrow mechanics, and delivery timing become part of the investment narrative.
The most common decision point is straightforward: commit to a new build well ahead of completion, or purchase a delivered residence where condition, view corridors, and day-to-day realities can be assessed immediately.
Two paths to ownership: Pre-construction versus Resale
At this tier, pre-construction is rarely about speculative appreciation. More often, it is about reserving a rare product early: preferred stacks, preferred exposures, and the ability to personalize finishes within the developer’s parameters. The tradeoff is time. You are underwriting entitlement, logistics, schedules, and the inherent unpredictability of building on a barrier island.
Resale is the opposite advantage. It prioritizes immediacy and clarity. Your capital stack is typically simpler, inspections and building documents can be reviewed in their final form, and the home you tour is the home you close on. In a true luxury market, that certainty often commands its own premium.
This is the practical lens buyers use to compare The Residences at Six Fisher Island and Palazzo della Luna. The question is not simply new versus existing, it is deferred commitment versus immediate certainty.
The Residences at Six Fisher Island: a staged commitment designed for scarcity
The Residences at Six Fisher Island has been positioned as the island’s final new waterfront development site, signaling both rarity and a finite horizon for comparable new product. It has been widely described as ultra-luxury, with 50 residences across an approximately 11-story building.
From the start, the project’s posture has emphasized controlled access. An invitation-only approach was publicly highlighted, a tone that aligns with how many private buyers prefer to transact: quietly, selectively, and without the optics of a showroom scramble.
Design credits are also central to the pitch. The project is marketed with architecture by Kobi Karp and interiors by Tara Bernerd and Partners. On Fisher Island, “new” is evaluated less by novelty and more by whether the execution raises the bar.
The differentiator that most directly affects buyer strategy, however, is the financial structure. Six Fisher Island’s publicly shared deposit schedule is staged as follows:
- 20% at contract
- 10% due 90 days after contract
- 10% at “top-off”
- 60% due at closing
In practical terms, 40% is due prior to closing. Within South Florida luxury pre-construction, where staged deposits commonly total roughly 30% to 50% before closing, this sits in an established range. What matters is the behavioral impact: the majority of the buyer’s cash outlay remains deferred until delivery.
For many ultra-high-net-worth buyers, deferral is not about affordability. It is about optionality, balance-sheet efficiency, and keeping capital deployed elsewhere while still securing a place in a constrained pipeline.
Palazzo della Luna: a finished asset with different leverage
Palazzo della Luna represents the opposite advantage: delivery has already occurred. Reported as completed in 2019, it is a 50-residence building on Fisher Island marketed as designed by Kobi Karp, with interiors by Champalimaud Design.
In luxury real estate, “delivered” changes the decision calculus. Today, buyers typically encounter Palazzo della Luna through resale transactions rather than developer pre-construction contracts. That means:
- You can evaluate actual light, noise, and privacy in real time.
- Closing timelines are not tied to construction milestones.
- Negotiations can center on comparable resales, condition, and seller motivation rather than a published schedule.
Project marketing has described residence sizes roughly from about 3,724 square feet up to about 10,194 square feet, with substantial terraces and penthouse rooftop features. Launch-era pricing was marketed roughly from $6.5 million to $40 million, varying by residence type.
For buyers searching the secondary market for “Palazzo della Luna Fisher Island,” the appeal is often less about being first and more about being certain. You are buying a known building with a known presence on the island, which naturally attracts a different psychological profile than a multi-year build.
Deposits, escrow, and what you are really underwriting
Deposits in this market are not just transactional. On Fisher Island, they also act as signals of trust and alignment between buyer and developer, or buyer and seller.
In Florida condominium purchases, deposits are generally required to be held in escrow under Florida’s condominium escrow statute (Fla. Stat. §718.202), with additional restrictions and conditions that shape how and when funds can be used prior to closing. In other words, the where and when of your deposit is not merely custom, it is governed.
That framework helps explain why many Miami developments stage deposits across milestones, and why certain tranches are explicitly tied to construction events. Six Fisher Island’s top-off-linked payment is a clear example of a milestone-driven structure.
A resale purchase typically removes that milestone logic. You may place earnest money and proceed toward a comparatively near-term closing, but you are not wiring additional capital because a building reached a construction stage. Your underwriting shifts from “will it be delivered as promised” to “is this the right finished asset at this price.”
Timeline reality: delivery targets and the luxury cost of waiting
Public project trackers and market coverage have frequently cited delivery and closing around 2027 for Six Fisher Island, often referenced as Q1 2027. Buyers should treat timeline language as a target, not a guarantee. Construction sequences remain sensitive to permitting, logistics, and weather, and “top-off” timing is milestone-dependent.
This is where Fisher Island’s pricing power intersects with a buyer’s personal calendar. If your use case is immediate, or you are coordinating a broader portfolio repositioning, the opportunity cost of waiting can be meaningful, even at the highest net worth levels.
Conversely, if your objective is to secure a place in what is marketed as a final waterfront development opportunity, the waiting period can function as a premium paid in time rather than dollars.
Miami Beach alternatives when lifestyle is the priority
Some buyers start on Fisher Island, then expand the search across Miami Beach when they realize the decision is not only about seclusion. It is also about how you want to live day to day: walkability, restaurant adjacency, cultural proximity, and whether you prefer a resort-forward environment.
For those who want a more central Miami Beach rhythm while still prioritizing a private-residence experience, Shore Club Private Collections Miami Beach offers a different expression of luxury, one closely aligned with hospitality and the energy of the barrier island.
Others gravitate toward a branded, service-centric ecosystem where discretion is operationalized through staff and systems. Setai Residences Miami Beach is often considered in that set, particularly by buyers who value the choreography of arrivals, security, and daily support as much as the architecture itself.
These Miami Beach options are not substitutes for Fisher Island. They are alternatives that clarify what you are optimizing: privacy through geography, or privacy through design and service.
A buyer-oriented decision framework
When choosing between a new-build commitment and a finished building, the most useful questions are not philosophical. They are contractual, logistical, and personal.
Liquidity and timing
- If most of your cash outlay is deferred until closing, what is your plan if markets, rates, or personal circumstances change before delivery?
- If you buy a delivered resale unit, what is your tolerance for a faster close and immediate carry costs?
Execution risk
- In pre-construction, how are construction milestones defined and what constitutes “top-off” for deposit timing?
- What disclosures are provided about schedule targets, substitutions, and material changes?
Leverage and negotiation
- In a delivered building, you can negotiate against real comps and observable condition.
- In a scarcity-driven, invitation-forward launch environment, leverage may be expressed through access and selection rather than discounting.
Ultimately, the decision comes down to what you want to control. Six Fisher Island can offer early positioning and deferred capital deployment. Palazzo della Luna can offer immediacy and clarity.
FAQs
What makes Fisher Island’s 33109 market different? Scarcity and access are structural, and pricing reflects that. National coverage has reported 33109 as the most expensive U.S. ZIP code with a median around $9.5M.
Is The Residences at Six Fisher Island a pre-construction purchase? Yes. It is marketed as a new ultra-luxury condominium project with a multi-year timeline.
How many residences are planned at Six Fisher Island? The project has been marketed as 50 residences in an approximately 11-story building.
What is the Six Fisher Island deposit schedule? It is structured as 20% at contract, 10% at 90 days, 10% at top-off, and 60% at closing.
How much is due before closing at Six Fisher Island? Based on the published schedule, 40% is due pre-closing and 60% is due at closing.
What does “top-off” mean for buyers? It is a construction milestone tied to the building’s structural progress, and the timing can shift with the construction schedule.
Is Palazzo della Luna a new building? No. It was reported as completed in 2019, so most purchases today are resale transactions.
What is known about Palazzo della Luna residence sizing? Marketing materials described residences roughly from about 3,724 square feet up to about 10,194 square feet, with substantial terraces.
Do Florida rules protect condo deposits? Florida’s condo escrow statute generally requires deposits to be held in escrow, with rules that influence how deposits are handled prior to closing.
Which is better: buying new on Fisher Island or buying delivered? Neither is universally better. Pre-construction can offer early access and deferred capital deployment, while resale offers immediate certainty and faster use.
For private guidance on Fisher Island strategy and Miami Beach alternatives, speak with MILLION Luxury.
Million Luxury
Million Luxury
Welcome to MILLION, an exclusive luxury real estate boutique nestled in the heart of South Florida’s most desirable locations. Specializing in high-end properties, we provide a sanctuary for discerning clients including top Fortune 500 executives, affluent families, celebrities, and professional athletes from across the globe. At MILLION, we understand the unique demands of our elite clientele and offer a seamless blend of confidentiality and personalized attention. Our commitment to privacy is unwavering; we ensure that every transaction and interaction is handled with the utmost discretion and according to stringent confidentiality protocols. Our concierge service embodies the pinnacle of white-glove care, offering tailored assistance that transcends traditional real estate support.
